There is a legend that Johann Sebastian Bach’s sublime Chaconne, in his “Partita No. 2 in D Minor for Solo Violin”, was composed as a memorial to his first wife, Maria Barbara, who unexpectedly passed while Bach was away on a two-month work trip. It is based mostly on apocryphal evidence, and bolstered by certain musicological analyses pointing to salient themes/motifs common to that style of music; but really the main appeal of this theory is that it makes sense, to our contemporary sensibilities, that a work of such staggeringly intense emotive power could only come from a place of commensurate emotional intensity in the artist responsible for its creation.
Of course, there’s no solid reason to believe that this really was the case. Bach, in particular, actually seemed to be among the more quotidian of the canonical Western composers, as much of what has been passed down to posterity regarding his personal life consists of rather workaday details typical of any diligent craftsman, extraordinarily prolific though he was: Concerns over employment, instrumentation, the skills (or lack thereof) of the musicians available to him, etc. Much of this also arrives to us secondhand, from the reports of his colleagues and progeny—whoever Bach was to himself, in his own words, we have very little idea of.
But after Bach came Romanticism, and the notion of a composer producing a tour de force out of the welter of his deep mourning simply strikes the modern art lover as perfectly natural; and doubly so if such a work bears the sort of solemn profundity that the last movement of the Second Partita does. Beethoven, after all, had his Immortal Beloved—why shouldn’t his Baroque predecessor have something like that, too? Never mind that the man seemed to whip up masterpieces at the drop of a hat—his duties as Thomaskantor at Leipzig obligated him to compose a new cantata every week—or that the great artists end up creating their major works out of a wide range of inspirations and emotional contexts. His wife died, and he was not there to witness her death. Hence: Chaconne.
Something of the same fallacious (wishful? naive?) thinking seems to be at play with Hamnet, the latest film of Chloé Zhao’s adapted from the 2020 novel of the same name by Northern Irish writer Maggie O’Farrell. In this case, the speculation(s) center around that other unavoidable giant of the Western canon: William Shakespeare.
What if, the film (and book) posits, one of the most celebrated plays of all time, by the world’s most well-known playwright, has a hidden meaning? One hidden, really, in plain sight—an epigraph informs the viewer that, according to what can be gleaned from the regional/historical record, the names “Hamlet” and “Hamnet” were more or less interchangeable. Similar to Bach, not much is known about Shakespeare’s personal life, but it is documented that he had twins with Anne, or “Agnes,” Hathaway, named Hamnet and Judith, with the former dying at age 11 for no verifiable reason, though plague is the likely culprit. Hamnet was buried at the Church of the Holy Trinity at Stratford-upon-Avon in 1596; then, roughly a few years later, Shakespeare produces his tragedy, Hamlet.
In the intervening centuries, a not insignificant amount of ink has been spilled speculating on whether or not the two events are linked in any meaningful way. Certainly bereavement, and its subsequent depressions, is a major issue in Hamlet, and the father-son dynamic is not not a potential point of interest.
Despite there being many reasons to discount the theory as conjecture founded upon relatively thin evidence, at the end of the day, who’s to say what is true and what is not regarding the Bard’s intentions? History has cloaked so much of his life from us that to even build something like a psychological profile for Shakespeare requires the flourishing of at least a few imaginative liberties from the get-go. So why not make a story out of it? And to see him as a struggling husband, a grieving father, creating his art out of that most human of passions—Tragedy, from tragedy—would seem to render Shakespeare closer to us, and to perhaps demystify some of that particular play’s more perplexing elements. That is, if you can manage to avoid the sentimental pitfalls one risks by taking up such a conception…
Unfortunately, Hamnet‘s story opts not to.
A few things go awry for Hamnet, but the main, and intractable, issue with the film is its overweening tendency to bludgeon the viewer with emotional extremes: closeups of people sobbing, screaming in agony, harshly berating in the clearest of terms; a child dying horrifically in real time. There is no room for subtlety here, and the sensitive viewer must prepare themselves to be assaulted into an empathic response. It is normally a sign of weakness for a story when it relies on over-the-top episodes or scenery-chewing in order to move the audience, and Hamnet utilizes these in spades.
The script, co-adapted from the novel by both O’Farrell and Zhao, is an exercise in ham-fistedness with dialogue so flat, and periodically pseudo-profound, that one feels almost insulted on behalf of the writer whose work inspired the film and source material. Yes, to attempt high poesy in one’s dialogue as an homage to the Bard has its own set of risks, but it is at the very least ambitious. The same cannot be said for Hamnet, and in a particularly abysmal scene, even reproduces the “To be or not to be” soliloquy in perhaps the most obvious way possible.
A little on the plot, before continuing: Hamnet focuses less on Shakespeare than it does on Agnes Hathaway (Jessie Buckley), who is imagined here as the daughter of a forest witch (an herbalist of some kind, really, but gossiped about by the townspeople as an outsider). She is deeply connected to nature and very much an “instinct over reason” type of personality. The young Will (Paul Mescal) is smitten with her, and wins Agnes’s charms by relating to her the story of Orpheus and Eurydice. He is a Greek and Latin tutor, the son of a financially troubled glover, and writes poetry on the side like any angsty young man with artistic dreams. The next hour and a half or so follows their shotgun wedding, the birth of their children, and then the death of Hamnet. Agnes falls into despair, and cuts Will off emotionally for his London sojourns, as he is away when Hamnet dies. The very ending involves Agnes’s trip to London with her brother Bartholomew (Joe Alwyn) to see Will’s new play—where it is revealed to her as a tribute to their son, now gifted to the ages in defiance of death.
I’m all for shifting the focus off of William Shakespeare in a fictional take on his life (God knows it’s needed—we don’t need a repeat of something like Kenneth Branagh’s Bardolatrous dud All Is True) but in a film ostensibly about the “true” meaning of Hamlet, perhaps more time ought to have been served detailing the making of the play itself, and how specific elements were drawn from the Shakespeares’ biography as imagined by Zhao/O’Farrell.
Instead, the audience is left with a rather formulaic domestic drama centering on a character of unfortunately thin substance. The story attempts to buttress Agnes with a loner-defiance, a kind of witchy mystique, but whatever intrigue is there gets quickly overtaken by her (first cooperative, then begrudging) subservience to Will’s career and her new role as homemaker. Her only real defining feature is this woo-woo connection to the supernatural, as she experiences premonitions and even seems to commune with the spirit of Hamnet in the Globe Theatre, at film’s end. But this aspect is mainly played for cheap heartstring-tugs and some whispery clichés about death as the camera fixates on forest and field and sky (Zhao, a noted admirer of Terrence Malick, draws upon his worst tendencies, here).
Much of Hamnet‘s praise stems from the performance of the film’s lead. Now, it cannot be said that Buckley isn’t performing the hell out of the role—but that’s just it. Buckley, entirely capable of subtlety, is directed to wail and shriek and groan in her acutest agony, with Zhao’s camera shamelessly capturing every excruciating moment. And what mother wouldn’t, considering the family’s misfortune—but art is bigger than mere mimesis, and good acting is more nuanced than producing tears upon request. Of course, it’s the kind of acting that the Academy can’t get enough of, so one can expect Buckley to be hoisting an Oscar around this time next month. (Though, for my money, it should go to Rose Byrne in If I Had Legs, I’d Kick You; with Byrne, hysteria is admixed with humor, and is more richly shaded overall.)
As for the other performances – Mescal is generally decent but is quite overmatched here, by both his main scene partner and the figure he is required to portray. The too-obvious script does him no favors, and his reading of Hamlet’s soliloquy (intended, I suspect, to be recited as if improvised off the dome) is unconvincing. The children are all very good in that polished way many precocious young British child actors are, especially Jacobi Jupe’s Hamnet, who is tasked with acting through his own drawn-out death scene. The Globe’s Hamlet (in a neat meta touch, played by the younger actor’s older brother, Noah Jupe) is also serviceable, though his moment is ruined by schmaltz overload, when the whole audience, along with Agnes, reaches out their hands to him as he dies in the play’s final scene. The superb Emily Watson, disappointingly underutilized, does her darndest to complexify the minor supporting role of Will’s mother.
In terms of positives, Hamnet certainly looks incredible, with Lukasz Zal’s cinematography very reminiscent of Emmanuel Lubezki’s best work on post-90s Malick. It is lush with earthy tones to further emphasize Agnes’s connection with the environment, and adept at using natural light in alignment with the film’s period setting. It does contain some gorgeous shots, something Zhao has always been good at (ostensibly—I’ve only seen Eternals, a formulaic Marvel slopfest for which she should be only partially held accountable), though the effectiveness of these are dampened by the general atmosphere of the film, especially when it leans into the lugubrious.
The music by Max Richter is also effectively evocative, as is his wont; but again, even a good film score like Richter’s can be compromised by its fealty to melodrama, exemplified by that final On the Nature of Daylight needle-drop, a beautiful but now much-too-ubiquitous piece that may move some, here, but only served to irk this critic upon viewing, who was already aggrieved at being blatantly coerced into various states of tearfulness.
But, to build on an earlier point, perhaps the most needling sin of Hamnet is its rather simplistic treatment of the play itself. Yes, to think of Hamlet as a kind of Funeral Eucharist is certainly suggestive, but what then? Does this idea illuminate anything surprising about the work? Are there depths to the tragedy hitherto undiscovered because of this missing interpretation? And more importantly—what can this reading offer artistically, in order to breathe new life into a field of the arts that’s been continually plumbed for over four centuries?
Sadly, in this regard, the only thing Zhao’s Hamnet has to offer is silence.
* * *
If you enjoyed this review of Chloe Zhao’s HAMNET, consider supporting our film on a great American poet and get patron-only content on Patreon. This will help the growth of this site, the automachination YouTube channel, and the ArtiFact Podcast. Our video essays include a comparison between Palestine and Liberia, an investigation into the death of American journalist Paul Klebnikov in Moscow, and the role of white guilt in American politics. You can also follow us on Twitter.
More from Ezekiel Yu: Role Reversal: Reviewing Sam Raimi’s “Send Help” (2026), Good Girl: On Kelly Reichardt’s “Wendy and Lucy” (2008), Unmatched Expectations: On Whit Stillman’s “Metropolitan” (1990)


