Getting Squeezed: On Kenji Kamiyama’s “Lord of the Rings: War of the Rohirrim” (2024)

Nighttime with the world at war in Kenji Kamiyama's "Lord of the Rings: War of the Rohirrim".

Peter Jackson’s The Lord of the Rings trilogy were not the very first films I ever watched, but they certainly comprise the majority of my earliest memories regarding film. I keenly remember watching The Fellowship of the Ring at home on a DVD rented from Blockbuster, the whole family gathered around, as was our wont on weekend evenings. I was enthralled, and then shocked when it ended with the Hobbit heroes Frodo and Sam crossing some rocky precipice, Mount Doom and fire-flecked storms looming in the distance. The credits rolled, and I remember thinking, that can’t be the ending, can it? The quest wasn’t over, the Ring still had to be destroyed, so you can’t have an ending if the story hasn’t…well, ended.

Was this some twisted trick meant to disappoint spellbound young viewers? Dumbstruck before the TV glow, it was a kind of torture, this feeling, but at the same time was also a strange, new yearning for more.

I made a bit of a fuss, and my dad had to calm me down by informing me about the concept of “sequels.” I eagerly awaited the next installment(s), with the whole saga culminating in what was perhaps my most glorious theater experience up to that point: seeing The Return of the King on opening weekend, its infamously long running-time (and slew of false endings) going by in absolutely no time at all. I’d been sufficiently hooked, you see, since that night when my five or six year old self first found a taste for the epic, the fantastical, and I would spend the bulk of my childhood, for better or worse, in search of that same never-ending rush.

I eventually got to the books, which were in some ways more engaging and in others more opaque. (It’s sort of a hot take, but nowadays I think Jackson’s trilogy actually improved on aspects of the source material, which in many sections is, to be frank, a dull slog.) Like any budding Tolkienite, I did the requisite The Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales, etc. read-throughs so that words/phrases like “Ar-Pharazôn” and “The Sundering of the Elves” and “Glaurung” and other mostly useless factoids could be forever branded into my brain.

Of course, one grows up, and while my tastes eventually changed, my interest in fantasy, and J. R. R. Tolkien’s mythos, in particular, never fully went away. I followed the early-2010s development of (first Guillermo Del Toro’s, then) Peter Jackson’s The Hobbit with probably more optimism than was warranted, for no reason other than because I was excited to experience that world again—and from the same director, to boot. When all three (!) Hobbit films came out, I tolerated them, even when they were abysmal, because it was enough that I’d gotten the nostalgic fill of a resurrected piece of my childhood, and I could rest content with the thought that that portly Kiwi had milked the legendarium of whatever precious drops of filmic storytelling he could squeeze out of it…

…only for the Tolkien Estate to about-face and sell certain rights of the oeuvre to none other than Amazon (spinning the good professor in his grave at high enough velocities to power Project Kuiper’s satellite systems for an Age)—spawning yet another franchise, except this time in the form of a series on the company’s streaming service.

Well, fine then. Surely nothing of serious worth could result from this, but hey, I told myself, if you simply look at it as another excuse to re-visit this fictional wonderscape you loved as a kid, then what’s the harm?

Who cares if they’re casting non-white actors in “European” roles, and transforming what is essentially pseudo-mythopoeia into content for standard longform TV drama? Leave the complaining to reactionary scolds posing as art critics—you finally get to see Númenor onscreen! Eregion! My God: Celebrimbor, descendant of Fëanor, master-smith among the Noldor! And here I was thinking those silly old factoids were useless…

Two seasons, $1 billion, and many racist social media posts later, Amazon’s The Rings of Power truly is…a series, bearing a discernable plot involving characters with good motivations who are put into conflict against characters with evil motivations. There are “arcs” and such, and a story-map the length of at least five(!) made-to-order seasons, and panel appearances at conventions where the series creators must ritualistically establish their Tolkien bona fides only to be harangued by race-baiters out of some misplaced vitriol concerning “heritage” and “fidelity to the author’s intentions.” If it sounds like much ado about nothing, that’s because it is.

I, for one, am more or less satisfied with simply watching The Second Age of Middle-Earth visualized through a nonsensically high budget, and if that means stomaching line after line of clichéd aphorisms delivered in the poshest of RPs, and distractingly obvious CGI-galore set-pieces, then so be it.  Look, I thought, at least with Amazon at the helm of this shambling creation, there really isn’t any room for more Tolkien-inspired content, is there?

No matter the irony of a multi-national corporation owning rights to a work penned by a provincial, tree-hugging Oxford don who despised industrialization, or the bigotry of online morons, I could sit back and extract as much value from this well-intentioned mess as I pleased, knowing full well that this would be the last, the very last, of a broken lineage; and flawed though it may be, there were enough glimmers of what this grand saga once was that, even through the hasty exposition, the artificial gloss, and the absurdly stiff Elvish coiffure, I could be at peace with this recognition, as well as with my knowledge of the blessèd end of all things…

But alas! The sorcerous powers at New Line Cinema had future plans for past creations. The Kiwi’s work, despite his silence, was not yet done. Forces were marshaling in the East, and occasional screenwriter Philippa Boyens had once again unsheathed her rusted pen…

And so it came to pass that Kenji Kamiyama’s The Lord of the Rings: The War of the Rohirrim (2024) found its way into American theaters, and onto my weary, half-disbelieving eyes…

Moon warriors from Kenji Kamiyama's Lord of the Rings, War of the Rohirrim

It’s become a universally acknowledged notion that today’s media landscape is obsessed with nostalgia, constantly re-visiting either a bygone decade or reviving some beloved franchise in order to capitalize on the cult crazes surrounding said franchises.

We know it, they know it, and despite all the worries about IP regurgitation and the lack of originality, such content continues to be consumed at rates which do not exactly discourage studios from repeating themselves. For all the hand-wringing about so-called “superhero fatigue,” all it takes is one Deadpool & Wolverine to rake in tons of cash and make audiences forget about the dozens of other sub-mediocrities released previous to it. The same applies to Star Wars and Ghostbusters and Godzilla and on and on the cycle goes.

This is, to be fair, not exactly unprecedented phenomena, and neither is it “bad,” per se. There will always be products appealing to the Lowest Common Denominator (and even to us “arty” types), and franchises built upon such appeal will always continue to supply the demand, provided there is a demand. In an age where there seems to be nothing but demand for more of the same, the supply will likewise grow to ridiculous proportion.

So it should come as no great shock that Peter Jackson and co. decided to revisit the world of Tolkien as portrayed in their zeitgeist-defining trilogy with The Lord of the Rings: The War of the Rohirrim—if anything, the Amazon production only further justified this decision rather than presented itself as any dissuading obstacle. Demand, supply, etc.

Of course, it’s still important to package this retread as something “novel:” hence the inclusion of Kenji Kamiyama, of Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex fame (and in partnership with Warner Bros. Animation). “What if Lord of the Rings, but anime?” Not the absolute worst sales pitch, but a truly intriguing project would involve an auteur with a riskier vision, and a part of the legendarium never-before-seen.

Instead, the animation style of War of the Rohirrim, while quite slick and well-drawn, is fairly conventional, and the story, ever so boringly, is tied to the Jackson movies’ continuity. Set in Rohan, about a century prior to the events of the trilogy, it focuses on Princess Héra (Gaia Wise), daughter of King Helm “Hammerhand” (Brian Cox), who must rise to the defense of the kingdom when enemies within threaten to topple Helm’s dynasty from the throne.

The story (culled from a small section of one of The Lord of the Rings’s appendices, the writers took many liberties with the material considering its dearth of information) follows even more conventional tracks than the visuals: there is a headstrong anime-waifu princess who rebels against tradition, an outcast noble, Wulf (Luke Pasqualino), who vies for power, and pitched battle sequences where the bad guy almost wins only for the good guys to rally at the eleventh hour, etc.

A red-headed female warrior holding a sword from Kenji Kamiyama's Lord of the Rings, War of the Rohirrim

Because it is seen as a companion piece to Jackson’s trilogy, many of the same art designs from those movies are recycled here, notably for Edoras and Helm’s Deep. In fact, War of the Rohirrim is a veritable roll call of references to the trilogy: the return of Miranda Otto’s Éowyn to narrate the tale’s frame; the re-appearance of creatures like the oliphants and the Watcher in the Water; call-backs to famous lines of dialogue; and even a cameo involving a cast member from the trilogy who’d passed away long before the film even began development! Not even the dead, it seems, are allowed to die; certainly not when nostalgia-bait calls for their zombification.

There’s really not much else to recommend plot/character-wise, unfortunately. Well, the part where King Helm goes half-dead Hulk Hogan on the enemy army, and kicks the ass of a giant troll on the side—some smashing good fun in a story that’s otherwise dreadfully convinced of its own seriousness. All-around decent voice acting from the performers, especially Brian Cox, and the score, while annoyingly recapitulative of Howard Shore’s motifs, does what its supposed to do.

Considering the ancient nature of the narrative told here, one wonders why the script required four(!?) writers—not counting Philippa Boyens, who produced the film, along with Jackson—but the best thing that can be said about it is that its utter conventionality makes for easy watching, and the viewer can find at least some satisfaction by predicting the story-beats when they inevitably thud to their conclusions.

And, again, the animation style is professionally done: the entire film was performed by actors in a studio, and motion-captured in order for the animators to then hand-draw the 3D-copied performances for a more authentic feel. So, yes, the resulting fluidity of the animation is admirable, but it only goes so far considering the canned plot and characters.

One also wonders: why did this have to be done in the first place? Audiences, apart from a niche crowd, aren’t exactly clamoring for more The Lord of the Rings adaptations; and to be totally honest, beyond my own personal love for it, Jackson’s film trilogy is severely overrated, claimed by many as the greatest of all time despite being not even within sniffing distance of the top spot. It made a lot of money, yes, and won many awards for its historic production/popularity, but to echo Dan Schneider’s point, it does not hold a candle to the deeper, more daring trilogies of the likes of Ingmar Bergman or Michelangelo Antonioni. (To even compare them would be silly, as they operate on almost entirely separate planes of artistic creation!)

But of course, once one realizes that War of the Rohirrim was fast-tracked to production so that film adaptation rights for Tolkien’s novels wouldn’t be lost, the whys-and-wherefores clarify. Far be it from the studio heads at New Line to cede control over who can monopolize on nostalgia to those globalist, DEI freaks at Amazon! No, Middle-Earth must remain pure, lily-white, and free of Black elves and dwarves and unconventional beauty standards! Bezos must fall! Rise, Men of the West!

OK, in all seriousness, this was never going to be a great film, so why bother? Truthfully, on the night I chose to see it, I was bored, listless, and failing to make progress on the review I’d actually intended to write before this one. I browsed through the box offices and came upon The War of the Rohirrim, a little surprised that it was already out. I’d known of its existence, and had no strong desire to see it—really, The Lord of the Rings but anime? Please.—then, right on cue, a miniscule niggle of nostalgia made me think, sure, in all likelihood it’ll stink, but I mean, you get to see Rohan again, and just what if…?

That’s how they get you. It’s my own fault, really. At the very least, however, I discovered that a good method to beat writer’s block is to redirect your animus to something a little more snarky than appreciative critique. I’m also fully aware that most of the people who regularly visit this site probably aren’t Tolkienites, so I’m sure quite a few of the references and name-drops will fly over y’all’s heads—but trust me, at the rate Middle-Earth’s going right now, it’s better that way.

* * *

If you enjoyed this review of Kenji Kamiyama’s “Lord of the Rings: War of the Rohirrim”, consider  supporting our film on a great American poet and get patron-only content on Patreon. This will help the growth of this site, the automachination YouTube channel, and the ArtiFact Podcast. Recent episodes include a discussion of Benjamin Studebaker’s book on legitimation in liberal democracies, an analysis of Kamala Harris’s 2024 predicament, and a comprehensive look at art theory with critic Erik Hill.

More from Ezekiel Yu: The Mind’s Isle: On Rebecca West’s “The Return of the Soldier” (1918), The Swinging-Over: Reviewing Katherine Paterson’s “Bridge to Terabithia”, Between Two Lives, a Dream: Hayao Miyazaki’s “The Boy and the Heron” (2023)