Dreams and Bones: Reviewing Rodrigo Garcia’s “Nine Lives” (2005)

A stylized photographic still from Rodrigo Garcia's "Nine Lives" (2005), depicting a dinner party with champagne. Besides Amanda Seyfried (pictured), the film stars Sissy Spacek, Glenn Close, Holly Hunter, Lisa Gay Hamilton, Kathy Baker, Amy Brenneman, Robin Wright Penn, Aidan Quinn, K Callan, Dakota Fanning, Ian McShane, Mary Kay Place, Molly Parker, Sydney Tamiia Poitier, Elpidia Carrillo, Jason Isaacs, Miguel Sandoval, and Joe Mantegna.

The very first shot of Rodrigo Garcia’s Nine Lives is of a bright corridor inside a jailhouse, straight down its length, with the cell doors to the side all unmistakably shut. This establishes two things: 1) the location of Garcia’s first of nine explored lives, Sandra (Elpidia Carillo), who is incarcerated in this very jail, and 2) the idea that, in critic Dan Schneider’s words, this film is about how “people…are their own jailers” and are enclosed not only by circumstances outside their control but by the consequences of their freely-willed choices.

This is a prevailing theme of Nine Lives, and perhaps its most subtle, but it is certainly not the only one. Also at play is the connectivity of community, how relationships proliferate beyond even the small(er) understanding of any one participant; as well as the human tendency to invent a grand(er) narrative that coheres events together in order to make better sense of them.

Nine Lives is one of those so-called “hyperlink” films, where several plots interconnect and dovetail, with characters from each subplot potentially appearing in others, all under the guidance of an overarching theme. Think Nashville, Magnolia, or the films of Alejandro González Iñárritu (who is an executive producer on Nine Lives).

One of the best things about Garcia’s film, however, is that, unlike some of the aforementioned, there is no great effort to have all the plots neatly intersect in one (normally convoluted) ribbon, with all the characters meeting to some degree, by the end. In Nine Lives, the themes really do just guide, but there is no plot contrivance, and all the stories naturally flow together through not only the rather minor cameos of outside-characters, but by the ideas expressed and exchanged by the characters who are central to each story.

To try to have everything neatly connect at the end would be to counteract what is so powerful about the film: that each of these women are the protagonists of their own story (to recycle a trendy cliché), and in reality, although strangers do become entangled in larger-than-life events from time to time, what is more impressive is to portray the ordinariness of 90% of life, and yet somehow glean profundity and insight from what might otherwise sink into banality and/or melodrama.

True, many of these chapters (short films, in their own right) involve ruptures in the slipstream of the banal—a chance reunion with an old flame, the harrowing return of a mentally ill family member to her childhood home, a forbidden tryst at a funeral, etc.—but they never strain credulity, and the characters are fleshed-out enough so that the viewer gets a sense of their lives, their particular histories, outside the bounds of their screentime.

Garcia’s script is superb, and is lifted to even greater heights by his cast. He is keenly adept at suggesting backstory through remarks that obliquely reference the importance of some past event. The dialogue is understated, naturalistic, subtly poetic with its meta indications toward the overarching connection(s); the performances, anchored by the female leads, are perfectly matched to the spirit of that dialogue. This is acting achieved through what is unsaid in addition to what is said: sidelong glances, gestures, intense stares. For example, witness the marvelous two-hander (the bulk of Garcia’s best writing comes out in exchanges of this type) Diana and how actors Robin Wright Penn and Jason Isaacs fill in the silences of their nonverbal interactions.

Something, however, that might be less obvious to the non-reviewer, but is just as essential to the film’s artistic success as its strong writing and acting, is Rodrigo Garcia’s direction.

It should be obvious, yes, that the primary technique Garcia deploys is the one-take shot, as all the episodes are filmed in a long oner, with the lone exception saved for the final episode, Maggie, although the cut is hidden. What is the reasoning behind this? In Sandra, one of the officers calls the woman “ubiquitous,” deriding her activity around the prison—in the same way, Garcia’s camera (guided also by his cinematographer Xavier Pérez Grobet) is the ubiquitous presence in each short, the unseen medium through which the viewer gains access to these many lives.

But even more pointedly, the single-take allows Garcia’s camera to doggedly pursue the characters along the tracks they seem to obsessively follow. A great number of these characters, although as full-fledged a batch of creations as their screentime can accommodate are nevertheless caught in traps—whether they be traps of the past, of mental dysregulation, and/or toxic relationships.

It is telling how many of the women make continuous circuits around a confined space: Sandra in the prison, Diana through the supermarket (“they don’t give us a choice”), Samantha (Amanda Seyfried) caught between the warring polarities of her loving yet estranged parents—Garcia’s staging in this episode, in order to hammer home this point, is very well done. Sonia (Holly Hunter) has a phobia of elevators, which functions both as a character quirk and a way to metaphorize the stifling nature of her partner Martin’s (Stephen Dillane) resentful insecurities—the camera follows them inside that creaking contraption, too. Rodrigo is invested in exploring the situations of characters who cannot let go, who draw others into the pressure of their indecision.

A photographic still from Rodrigo Garcia's "Nine Lives" (2005), depicting a meeting in a supermarket between two former lovers.
“It was lovely by fits and starts.”

Some of them, like Camille (Kathy Baker), a woman about to undergo a double mastectomy, are relatively well-adjusted, with stable relationships—the camera with her is less adventurous, allowing the bickering banter of her and her husband (a pitch-perfect Joe Mantegna) to shine. It is here that some of Garcia’s best lines occur:

RICHARD: You know, you’re gonna have to try to relax. You’re just making it worse on yourself.

CAMILLE: We’re nothing, Rich. Do you ever think about that? We’re nothing.

RICHARD: (Overlapping) No, no. We’re a lot more than nothing.

CAMILLE: No, we’re fuckin’ nothing, we’re dreams and bones. You know what I hate, the surgeon doesn’t come in here to say hi to me. Touch base with me. He’s in there, hiding, waiting like an executioner. (Touching her lips) My mouth is so dry.

RICHARD: I’ll get you some water.

CAMILLE: (Sighing) I can’t drink anything. Hello? Does that ring a bell? Just sit. (Beat) You have that same face you’ve always had.

RICHARD: Well, that’s a relief.

CAMILLE: Try to understand what I’m saying to you.

RICHARD: What’re you saying?

CAMILLE: I’m saying you…I don’t know. It’s got something to do with…Fuck, do I have to explain myself always? (Turns away) (Beat) (Faces him again) You were a stranger once.

If you’ve ever been in the midst of some health crisis at a hospital, then the stuttering track of this conversation, the nerves, the almost accidental dips into profundity, etc. should be utterly familiar. And the camera holds through it all.

The obsessive lengths of the takes not only creates a stage for the actors to strut their stuff, if you will, but gives ample time and space for the characters to unveil more of their inner conflicts and desires, unimpeded by cuts, flashbacks, time-skips, POV switches, etc. This gives Garcia less wiggle room to avoid stereotype and handy tacks for his situations to take, of course, but once again, he is too skilled a storyteller to let those develop.

And although there is no convoluted greater plot wrapping all these varying stories in a nice bow, Nine Lives does have a fitting, rounded-out feel to it. The very beginning with Sandra takes place in a prison, and the very end in a graveyard. In both, certain thresholds are passable only under certain conditions—and finality looms over all. There are mothers and daughters, and how each has come to accept their situation determines their present state and, perhaps, their future. There is weeping and gnashing of teeth, and there is peace. What, and how, do they choose?

Nine Lives is the sort of work that, due to its very subtleties, is easy to underrate. There is no harrowing mystery to solve, or some quasi-MacGuffin (think the rifle in Babel) that interlocks disparate narratives—the issue, here, is simply life, and the people who populate each other’s lives; people whose significance escapes attention because attention, all too often, is not being paid. We should be grateful Rodrigo Garcia has paid enough attention to masterfully limn these significances.

* * *

If you enjoyed this review of Rodrigo Garcia’s NINE LIVES, consider supporting our film on a great American poet and get patron-only content on Patreon. This will help the growth of this site, the automachination YouTube channel, and the ArtiFact Podcast. Recent episodes include a discussion of Benjamin Studebaker’s book on legitimation in liberal democracies, an analysis of Kamala Harris’s 2024 predicament, and a comprehensive look at art theory with critic Erik Hill.

More from Ezekiel Yu: Control Your Self: on Coralie Fargeat’s “The Substance” (2024), And Fate Disposes: On Terence Davies’s “The Long Day Closes” (1992), New Hands, Same Stakes: On Robert Eggers’s “Nosferatu” (2024)