I’m always receptive to stories about those artists who were overlooked in their lifetimes. Not that I deliberately seek out disappointment per se (a contradiction, I’ll admit), but if I happen to chance upon it, I’ll likely remember it. One such time occurred on a Friday afternoon while listening to a radio station called Simply Beautiful 91.3 KNCT-FM, which will play anything from Sam Cooke to Jim Croce, Glenn Miller to Glenn Gould, instrumental to swing, jazz, and random folk. (It can be assumed that most of Simply Beautiful’s audience is older, so it’s no surprise to hear this station playing while browsing in a local antique store.)
So, it was upon this Friday afternoon when I first chanced upon an unfamiliar folk song called ‘The Kiss’, followed by the DJ mentioning the name Judee Sill and the documentary Lost Angel. (Scribbling down the name and title, I misspelled her name as Judy.) It’s been said that Sill had a rough start in life, having been a heroin addict, a prostitute, and spending time in jail. However, despite these setbacks, Sill managed to create two albums (titled Judee Sill and Heart Food) both containing elements of country, blues, gospel, and Bach Fugues. An odd combination, I admit, and so afterward I immediately searched her Spotify channel and began playing what sounded like an ethereal mix of reflection, meditation, and religion. Then, upon watching the documentary Lost Angel: The Genius of Judee Sill, her work and life became all the more illuminating.
So just who was this troubled woman named Judith Lynn Sill (1944-1979), a talented musician with a life cut short, and why is she, given her musical quality, not well known? Immediately, I was put in mind of another 1970s folk/rock singer named Sixto Rodriguez who, despite his commercial success in South Africa, remained unknown in the US. His lack, however, can be attributed to poor marketing, as well as other factors that the documentary Searching for Sugar Man addresses.
But Judee Sill continues to remain a mystery. For one, she did not suffer from promotional lack like Rodriguez did—quite the contrary. With contemporaries like Joni Mitchell, Linda Ronstadt, Jackson Browne, The Eagles, among others—all signed by Asylum Records—there was no doubt a pressure to succeed. However, watching them rise while she sadly lagged left Judee feeling disappointed, despite continuing to open for well-known artists like Gordon Lightfoot and Crosby, Still, Nash, and Young. Furthermore, her songs continually praised by many musicians in her day and even today, failed to reach the commercial success highs that one achieves via resonating with the average listener. Hence Judee Sill remains, in a sense, a musician’s musician.
Not that there is anything wrong with this per se (James Joyce is, after all, a writer’s writer), but most every artist wants some sort of societal recognition, even if they deny it—they still secretly crave it. (I don’t believe that Franz Kafka really wanted his books to be burned, but I digress.) In Lost Angel, we hear Judee’s throaty voice lamenting over her desire to be the greatest songwriter of her time, followed by her need to write slowly—‘If it takes me five years to make my next album, then that’s the time it takes,’ she says. ‘I don’t want to write shit.’
Born in 1944, Judee Sill suffered a traumatic childhood following the death of her beloved father. Afterward, her mother’s remarriage proved to be disastrous for Judee, as the documentary alludes to her stepfather having sexually abused her (exposing himself), among other traumas. Living out of a car, Sill resorted to armed robbery for drug money, eventually leading her to jail. Her musical talent, however, remained the crux of her creative focus. I imagine this is akin to the little voice inside every artist’s head that says, ‘Look, if you want to be great, you’re going to have to get your act together—at least for a while.’
As I write, I listen to Sill’s Spotify channel for music that is complex, nuanced, interesting, and enjoyable. Yet I can see how the average listener might find her songs dragging a bit, as in, too easily the lyrics can disappear into the background. Now, keep in mind that I am not a musician and that this is only my subjective opinion, but I do think that Sill might be far too esoteric for the average ear. However, despite her musical complexity, admittedly I find her music less accessible, and shall I say less catchy, than someone like Rodriguez. Even the documentary mentions, I believe from Clive Davis, that there seems to be a lack of a commercial ‘hook’ to her work. And music, being a more ‘primal’ art than film or fiction, requires a certain likeability for people to engage with it. As example, I can appreciate a film, book, poem, or painting that I don’t necessarily like emotionally, but still I am able to recognize the quality and learn from it. However, no amount of justification for the artistic intricacy of death metal is going to get me to listen to it.
This is not meant to be a reproach, but rather an explanation as to why Sill has not garnered the attention she so deserves. Also, the film notes that her average looks might have played a factor, given that Sill was not conventionally attractive according to 1970s Los Angeles standards. It is possible, however, that had she been born later and thrived during the 1990s Lilith Fair era, she would have done well among that crowd. The 1970s were a complex time—one either made it or not, and while I don’t like the idea of using one’s pain and suffering as justification for art, Sill’s traumatic story would have without a doubt resonated within the Sylvia Plath/Anne Sexton rejuvenated era of the mid-90s, where most everyone—especially women memoirists—had trauma to share.
Lost Angel: The Genius of Judee Sill is a well-done documentary that encompasses interviews with many who knew her, providing insights alongside her drawings that, coupled with the words in her journals, evoke the vulnerability of a talented, troubled musician. We all like to imagine the suffering artist succeeding, and it crushes us to think that trauma could have gotten the best of the greatest. Sadly, Judee Sill overdosed and died too young, and appeared ‘like a flower that never was able to grow into a tree,’ one interviewer said. However, this film is not a sob story, but rather a celebration of her contribution to a melody that will undoubtedly become more known among younger generations.
Who knew this LA girl opening for Gordon Lightfoot could produce such unmistakable complexity, bringing about vulnerable and intellectual lyrics that, combined with her resolve, would offer the world a little more flavor? No great artist is ever lost.
* * *
If you enjoyed this review of LOST ANGEL: THE GENIUS OF JUDEE SILL, consider supporting our film on a great American poet and get patron-only content on Patreon. This will help the growth of this site, the automachination YouTube channel, and the ArtiFact Podcast. Recent episodes include an analysis of Kamala Harris’s 2024 predicament, a dissection of the post-Gaza Middle East, and a comprehensive look at art theory with critic Erik Hill.
More from Jessica Schneider: A Good Biopic Is Hard to Find: Ethan Hawke’s “Wildcat” (2023), Romance Before Texting: Steve Martin’s “Roxanne” (1987), Metal, Stone, & Zip Codes: On Chantal Akerman’s “News From Home” (1976)

