Beware the Man in the Rubber Suit: Jack Arnold’s “Creature From the Black Lagoon” (1954)

A shot from Jack Arnold's "Creature from the Black Lagoon", depicting an Kay (Julie Adams) swimming on the surface as she is stalked by the Creature.

I recently visited an old bookstore with an accompanying antique shop that contained a trove of old novels, many from the 1940s. One such author I uncovered was the obscure Kathleen Norris—the specific book’s title, I don’t remember, only the tagline: she chose love over security, coupled with a melodramatic 1940s picture of a man and woman seated together. Or maybe he was holding her in a rescue pose. The premise, I think, was that the woman decided to run away with a guy who might not have been the greatest, but as long as he’s handsome then all is good. This put me in mind of the 1954 camp classic Creature From the Black Lagoon, and most specifically the character of Kay Lawrence (played by Julia Adams) who, like most women characters of this time, finds herself in need of rescue but not before screaming. The connection, I suppose, is that neither the 1940s novel nor the 1954 camp sci-fi film is particularly complex in its storytelling, yet both manage to bring about hokey entertainment.

 

First, how does one even begin to review a film like this? The costume is cheesy, and the creature’s gills and arms look like rubber—beware of the man in the rubber suit! The Creature appears out of the water’s shadows, lurking like he has somewhere to be, but isn’t sure. Just who are these human beings infesting his terrain, and what trouble do they bring? In short, we have a couple of ‘scientists’ (one good and one sort of evil who is out for himself) researching the Amazon for this strange creature in what has been called the ‘Black Lagoon,’ after having found a fossilized, finned hand. Dr. David Reed (Richard Carlson) is an ichthyologist who endearingly speaks like an encyclopedia and has a romance with Kay, who seems impressed by his handsome brilliance and sexy swim trunks. Unlike some other films where the characters are braving the Amazon, Creature From the Black Lagoon remains light-hearted even as it tries to take itself seriously. After all, one can’t help but chuckle over the melodramatic music each time we witness the Creature’s presence. Da-da-DA!!! Da-da-DA!!!

 

This is not to say the film doesn’t have moments of depth, and even beauty, such as the underwater scenes where Kay swims amid a submerged jungle, only to have the Creature eying her from afar. In what is probably the most famous scene, we get a glimpse of her from below as she glides across the water’s surface—light and pure she appears—only to then have the Creature swim beneath her in some hint of sexual longing. Think about it though—the poor thing. He’s sad. He’s just living his underwater life within his Black Lagoon, only to have these annoying humans show up. Then, in their attempt to possibly capture him, they lower poison into the water, managing to kill all the fish. Great job, assholes. Ruin the ecosystem. Also, there is a hint of pathos when Kay nonchalantly (and disrespectfully) throws her cigarette into the water, only for the Creature to eye it from below. Once again, these humans have no consideration for the life that has been here before. 

 

All this remains ironic, since in actuality, we end up cheering for the Creature over the annoying humans. (You’d think he’d just swim off but curiosity is keeping him around—ooh-la-la.) Furthermore, the film is not without its sexism for the time, where the men wonder if bringing a woman along would be a smart thing to do, but thankfully Julia Adams manages to transcend the stereotype somewhat, as she’s not merely presented as a ‘clueless appendage,’ but actually someone who knows a scientific thing or three. Granted, her outfits and stylish bathing suits don’t make sense given the humid, inhospitable terrain, but hey, this was the 1950s.

 

Last year I reviewed the 2001 film The Lost Skeleton of Cadavra, poking fun of films like this, and one can see Black Lagoon’s influence, especially with the fake, rubber costume that appears in the 2001 film. However, despite its low budget (and use of obvious rear projector) Creature From the Black Lagoon is quite entertaining, and just that sort of something one might want to watch late on a weeknight or weekend afternoon. Yet anytime one examines a film of any era, one must see how it holds up to the present day. Eventually, the Creature manages to crawl out of the water and onto the boat (he does so several times) in an attempt to ‘kidnap’ Kay by dragging her under the water and into his cave/abode. Reminiscent of King Kong, one might presume that he has a little crush, in that distinguishable, misunderstood monster sort of way.

 

While Creature From the Black Lagoon is without a doubt good camp, it manages to stand on its own and is more mature-looking and better written than something like Ed Wood’s Plan 9 (also good camp, albeit in a different way). Following the 1954 release of Black Lagoon, there have been several sequels that I remember watching years ago, but they don’t hold up in my memory to the original. Some have even labeled this film a ‘romance’ albeit one-sided, to say the least. Oh, you poor Creature—you just long to be near the pretty lady.  

 

Many have imbued meaning into the Creature as a representation of some sort of sexual longing or desire, and this could be true, but also the film seems to be a commentary on how humans treat those they might not relate to or understand. Add to that a disregard for nature, and one could say that this sounds like something that continues to persist among the humans of today. Indeed, the Creature seems to be more sensitive and aware than those humans living above water. Who are the monsters here?

 

* * *

If you enjoyed this review of Jack Arnold’s CREATURE FROM THE BLACK LAGOON, consider supporting our film on a great American poet and get patron-only content on Patreon. This will help the growth of this site, the automachination YouTube channel, and the ArtiFact Podcast. Recent episodes include an analysis of Kamala Harris’s 2024 predicament, a dissection of the post-Gaza Middle East, and a comprehensive look at art theory with critic Erik Hill.

More from Jessica Schneider: POETRY: Luncheon on the Grass (After Manet), As Is: Reviewing Jim Jarmusch’s “Paterson” (2016), Portrait of Pathos: Reviewing Ethan Hawke’s “Blaze” (2018)